CO2 vs. Thulium Laser: Which Is Better for Your Sun Damage?

A hilltop castle at a magenta sunset with a steep footpath and a winding road, a nod to choosing CO2 vs. thulium laser.

Written by Alexander Bonato, MD, board-certified in Internal Medicine by the American Board of Internal Medicine (ABIM) · Updated November 17, 2026

TL;DR: In the CO2 vs. thulium laser choice, I usually start with the 1927 nm thulium laser (NOUVADerm) when sun damage is mostly brown spots, uneven tone and rough texture, and with fractional CO2 when it includes etched wrinkles, crepey texture or acne scars and you can take about 7 to 10 days of social downtime. Thulium usually means about a week of visible healing, often over a series of three, and most people are back to normal activities within a day or two. No trial has compared the two head to head, so this verdict comes from how each laser works, indirect studies and your exam.


A few years ago my wife and I were in Italy with my parents, at the bottom of a hill with a castle on top. Two ways up. A little shuttle bus, on a road with a serious cliff drop on one side. Or a footpath.

I looked at that road for three seconds and decided it wasn't a risk I needed. So my wife and I hiked. Straight up, in the heat, with me explaining the whole way why this was the sensible choice.

My parents, very reasonably, took the bus.

We beat them to the top. I'd love to say that was the plan. It wasn't.

Anyway. Lasers. The question I hear most at laser consultations is some version of "the CO2 or the thulium?" and honestly, it's that hill. One route's steep and over sooner. The other takes its time. Except with lasers, the two routes don't always end at the same castle. I'm a physician board-certified in Internal Medicine (American Board of Internal Medicine) at Bonato MD Aesthetics in Medford. I offer both lasers, and every treatment here is 100% physician-done, from prescription to procedure, so I have a stake in both answers.

Sun Damage Isn't One Problem

"Sun damage" is a bundle. It can mean brown spots and freckling, uneven tone, rough texture, fine lines, deeper etched wrinkles, crepey skin, or rough, scaly precancerous spots called actinic keratoses. Most people have a mix, and which part bothers you most is the biggest clue to which laser fits.

CO2 vs. Thulium Laser: Same Pattern, Very Different Depth

Both lasers are fractional. They treat a grid of microscopic columns and leave the skin between them untouched, and that untouched skin is what you heal from.

Fractional CO2 is ablative. Each column vaporizes a tiny core of skin and leaves a rim of heated tissue around it. At higher energy those columns run deep. In a lab study of human skin, a CO2 column at a higher setting measured about 1 mm deep.1 My CO2 is the Phoenix, and its depth is adjustable, from a lighter pass to deep resurfacing. The longer version is in how fractional CO2 laser resurfacing works.

The 1927 nm thulium laser, which in my clinic is the NOUVADerm, is non-ablative at the settings typically used. Water absorbs that wavelength so strongly that the energy stays near the surface, in the top layer of skin and the upper dermis. In an imaging study, low-energy 1927 nm treatment stayed mostly in that top layer, about a tenth of a millimeter deep.2 At high energy it can remove a little surface too. I cover the wavelength itself in the 1927 nm thulium laser explained.

In picture form, CO2 is a renovation that goes down to the subfloor. Thulium refinishes the hardwood.

What the Studies Actually Compare

No randomized trial, and no split-face trial, has put CO2 and 1927 nm thulium against each other on the same people. I looked hard.

The closest thing is a chart review from one practice of 730 people treated with one of three fractional lasers, including a CO2 and a 1927 nm.3 CO2 produced more improvement in wrinkles and in the folds beside the nose and mouth. The 1927 nm laser produced the most improvement in pigment. Complications were 6.4% with CO2 and 4.0% with the 1927 nm laser, and that difference wasn't statistically significant.

Worth being straight about that one. It looked back at records, different people got different lasers for different reasons, one technician scored the results, the devices weren't mine, and I've only read the abstract. It points a direction. It doesn't settle anything. Everything else in this post is indirect: each laser studied on its own, or against a third laser. None of the CO2 studies I cite used my Phoenix. The thulium studies I cite are generally small, and the ones using the Lavieen laser were mostly in Asian or Brazilian patients, so treat their numbers as direction, not a forecast.

Wrinkles, Brown Spots or Acne Scars: Which Laser for Which Problem

Wrinkles and deeper lines

In that one chart review, CO2 produced more wrinkle improvement than the 1927 nm laser,3 which fits the physics of a deeper laser. The thulium laser can soften fine surface lines, but deeper wrinkles usually respond better to a deeper laser.

Brown spots and sun damage

This is thulium's home turf. Both lasers can improve sun-damaged skin, but in the same review the 1927 nm laser produced the most improvement in pigment,3 with a much shorter recovery. Sun-driven spots can come back, so daily sunscreen matters.

Acne scars

Pooled trials lean toward ablative lasers like CO2, but not unanimously: a network meta-analysis of 26 randomized trials favored ablative over non-ablative lasers,4 while a meta-analysis of 8 studies found no significant difference.5 Thulium for acne scars is off-label. In a split-face trial of 27 people, it improved scar scores about 36%, similar to a non-CO2 laser.6 Narrow ice-pick scars respond less well to CO2 alone,8 as I cover in why ice-pick scars are so stubborn.

Melasma and precancerous spots

For melasma, the thulium laser is an add-on at most, alongside sunscreen and prescription creams, and that use is off-label. In a small pilot, the improvement at one month was no longer statistically significant by three and six months,9 and in a longer follow-up, melasma came back in 7 of 15 people.10

Actinic keratoses need an exam first. The main dermatology guideline makes no recommendation on 1927 nm lasers,11 so I don't treat thulium as a first-line replacement for standard treatments.

The NOUVADerm's labeled uses are benign brown spots like sun spots and freckles, actinic keratoses, and soft-tissue coagulation. Using it for wrinkles, texture, general sun damage, acne scars or melasma is off-label.

If one laser did everything, I'd only need one laser. The clinic floor plan would be thrilled.

CO2 vs. Thulium Side by Side

Fractional CO21927 nm thulium (NOUVADerm)
How it worksAblative; about 1 mm deep at a higher setting (lab study)1Non-ablative at typical settings; about 0.1 mm deep at low energy (imaging study)2
Common usesDeeper lines, crepey texture, rolling and shallow acne scars, heavier sun damageBrown spots, sun damage, uneven tone, rough texture, fine lines
RecoveryFull strength: about 7 to 10 days social downtime; healed around day 7 to 10; crusting and flaking 1 to 2 weeks; pinkness about 1 to 2 weeks, longer after deeper treatments. Lighter (my counseling figures): redness typically 1 to 2 days, light peeling about a weekAbout a week of visible healing; normal activities in a day or two; crusting 3 to 5 days in trials6,7
SessionsOne full-strength, or 2 to 3 lighter at least 4 to 6 weeks apart. Expert panel (opinion): one for types I to II, several for III to IV12Clinic: usually 3, 4 to 6 weeks apart. Systematic review: protocols averaged 3, monthly13
Skin type and pigment riskMost predictable in types I to III; IV to VI off-label, case by case. Darkening 55.5% at 1 month, 11.1% at 6 months in a small study (9 people, types III to IV)14Priming for type III+; V and VI case by case. Expert recommendations tie darkening risk to energy and density15; no adverse events in a small low-energy review of types IV to VI treated for existing darkening16
Evidence limitsNo head-to-head trial, one chart review3; none with my Phoenix; scar meta-analyses disagree4,5Small trials; Lavieen studies mostly in Asian or Brazilian patients; melasma gains often faded9,10
Cost at my clinic$2,500 full-strength; $1,000 per lighter sessionNOUVAGlo $600; full-face series of three $3,000
Choose the other ifMostly brown spots, no week to spare, or type IV+ skinDeeper wrinkles or rolling and shallow acne scars; one tough week over a series
Two striped layer-cake blocks, one with a caramelized top only and one with deep channels, a nod to laser depth.

Depth vs. Downtime: What Each Week Actually Looks Like

At full strength, plan on about 7 to 10 days of social downtime with CO2. The surface typically heals around day 7 to 10, crusting and flaking last 1 to 2 weeks, and makeup is usually fine once the crusting has resolved. Pinkness is often about 1 to 2 weeks and can last longer after deeper treatments, and you'll need to stay out of direct sun for at least 4 weeks. After a lighter CO2 session, I typically counsel about 1 to 2 days of redness and light peeling for about a week. The day-by-day version is in what the week after CO2 actually looks like.

Thulium feels like a moderate sunburn at first. Around day 2 to 5 the skin turns bronzed and sandpapery, then flakes off around day 5 to 10. Most people are back to normal activities within a day or two, with makeup once the peeling is done.

In hill terms, CO2 is the steep footpath. Thulium is the switchbacks.

One Big Session or a Series?

With CO2, the setting decides the plan. An expert consensus panel leaned toward one high-setting treatment for lighter skin and several milder ones for skin types III and IV, though that's opinion, and the panel had ties to a CO2 laser maker.12 In my clinic, a single full-strength treatment is often enough for significant sun damage, texture or scarring, and lighter CO2 treatments are usually a series of 2 to 3, at least 4 to 6 weeks apart.

With thulium, it's usually a series. A systematic review found protocols averaged 3 sessions at monthly intervals.13 Most of my plans are 3 treatments about 4 to 6 weeks apart, and some concerns respond to a single lighter NOUVAGlo session. That's my practice, not a trial result.

So the real calendar question is one long week of hiding or a few short ones.

Skin Type and Safety: The Part I'll Keep Plain

The main risk for both lasers in medium to darker skin is temporary darkening after treatment, called post-inflammatory hyperpigmentation. In the studies I've read, it's generally more likely with CO2 and with more aggressive settings. In a small CO2 study of 9 people with skin types III and IV, 55.5% had darkening at one month and 11.1% at six months.14 So it's often temporary, but it isn't always quick.

My CO2 gives its most predictable results in skin types I to III. Treating types IV to VI is off-label. I consider it case by case, with modified settings and a series of gentler sessions, and for many people another treatment is a better fit.

With thulium, expert recommendations tie the darkening risk in skin of color to the energy and density used.15 At low-energy settings, a retrospective review of 61 people with skin types IV to VI, who were being treated for existing darkening, reported no adverse events.16 These studies are small, with very little data in types V and VI. For type III and above I use several weeks of skin priming and gentler settings, and types V and VI are case by case. There's more in whether the thulium laser is safe for darker skin tones.

Other risks differ by depth. In a review of 490 deep fractional CO2 treatments, 13.6% had a side effect, most often acne-like breakouts (5.3%) or cold sore flares (2.2%), with no scarring reported.17 Rarely, CO2 can cause scarring or lasting loss of skin color, sometimes appearing months later. Thulium's risks are usually milder, with infection and scarring rare. If you've had cold sores, tell me. With that history, an antiviral is part of the plan.

None of this is meant to scare you off either laser. It's the conversation we'll have, slowly, before anything gets scheduled.

What CO2 and Thulium Cost at My Clinic

A full-strength fractional CO2 treatment is $2,500, as one session. Lighter CO2 treatments are $1,000 per session. NOUVAGlo, the lighter NOUVADerm treatment, is $600 for a single session. A full-face thulium series at higher settings is $3,000 for three sessions, which is more than one CO2 treatment because you're comparing three treatments to one.

So Who Fits Which Laser?

Here's how I weigh it: your main concern, how much downtime you can take, your skin type, and whether you'd rather do one tougher week or a short series. Your exam decides, and this is practice, not a trial result.

  • CO2 tends to make more sense if deeper lines, crepey texture or rolling and shallow acne scars are the main issue, your skin type is I to III, and you can take about 7 to 10 days of social downtime.
  • Thulium tends to make more sense if brown spots, sun damage, uneven tone or rough texture are the main issue, you'd rather heal for a few days at a time, or you have medium to darker skin and want a more conservative route.

When neither laser is the right first step

Neither is a facelift. When the real issue is loose, heavy skin or lost volume, a different tool fits better. Narrow ice-pick scars usually need a targeted approach first. Melasma starts with sunscreen and prescription creams. And a rough, scaly spot gets examined before anyone points a laser at it. I'll tell you if that's you.

I picked my route up that hill because of a cliff. You get to pick yours with a lot more information.

Questions to Bring to Your Consultation

  • What's my main concern, pigment, texture, wrinkles or scars?
  • What's my skin type, and does it change which laser or settings you'd use?
  • How many days of downtime should I actually plan for at the settings you'd choose?
  • One treatment or a series, and how far apart?
  • What would make you recommend something other than a laser?

Frequently Asked Questions

Is CO2 or thulium better for wrinkles?

For deeper wrinkles, CO2 is usually my first choice, because it reaches deeper, and the one large chart review found more wrinkle improvement with it,3 though there's no head-to-head trial. Thulium can soften fine surface lines, an off-label use.

If you're mostly bothered by brown spots instead, the answer flips. Lasers are picky like that.

Which laser has less downtime?

Thulium. Expect about a week of visible healing, with most people back to normal activities within a day or two. Full-strength CO2 usually means about 7 to 10 days of social downtime and pinkness that is often about 1 to 2 weeks, though it can last longer after deeper treatments.

Either way, I'd skip booking it the week of a wedding. Yours or anyone's.

Let's Pick Your Route Together

Stuck between the two? That's a good place to be. Bring your questions, your calendar and your honest sun habits.

I see patients from Medford, Ashland and Grants Pass. You can read more about CO2 laser resurfacing in Medford and NOUVADerm thulium laser skin rejuvenation in Medford. Book a free consultation, or call or text 541-243-7546. A foggy Rogue Valley winter, with nothing on the lake calendar, is honestly a pretty convenient time to be pink for a week.

No shuttle bus required.

Your treatment plan is determined at your consultation with Dr. Bonato.

References

  1. Hantash BM, et al. Ex vivo histological characterization of a novel ablative fractional resurfacing device. Lasers Surg Med. 2007;39(2):87-95. https://doi.org/10.1002/lsm.20405 (Laboratory study of human skin samples; depth depends on device and energy; not the Phoenix CO2.)
  2. Wenande E, Jacobsen K, Grove GL, et al. Imaging 1927 nm fractional thulium laser-tissue interactions: a spectrum of nonablative to ablative effects. J Cosmet Dermatol. 2025;24(7):e70304. https://doi.org/10.1111/jocd.70304 (Imaging study in a single subject; a different 1927 nm device, not NOUVADerm.)
  3. Cohen SR, et al. Clinical outcomes and complications associated with fractional lasers: a review of 730 patients. Aesthetic Plast Surg. 2017;41(1):171-178. https://doi.org/10.1007/s00266-016-0767-x (Retrospective chart review from one practice; not randomized; different patients per laser; results scored by one technician; mostly skin types I–III; other device brands.)
  4. Li MY, et al. Effectiveness and safety of energy-based devices for acne scars: a network meta-analysis of randomized controlled trials. Facial Plast Surg Aesthet Med. 2023;25(6):521-527. https://doi.org/10.1089/fpsam.2022.0383 (Network meta-analysis of 26 RCTs; indirect comparisons; no difference in patient satisfaction; ablative lasers associated with more pain.)
  5. Zhang DD, et al. The efficacy of fractional CO2 laser in acne scar treatment: a meta-analysis. Dermatol Ther. 2021;34(1):e14539. https://doi.org/10.1111/dth.14539 (Meta-analysis of 8 studies; no significant difference between CO2 and non-CO2 lasers.)
  6. Lu K, Cai S. Efficacy and safety comparison between 1927 nm thulium laser and 2940 nm Er:YAG laser in the treatment of facial atrophic acne scarring: a prospective, simultaneous spilt-face clinical trial. Lasers Med Sci. 2022;37(3):2025-2031. https://doi.org/10.1007/s10103-021-03465-0 (Randomized split-face trial, n=27, skin types III–V; compared with a 2940 nm erbium laser, not CO2; 3 sessions; 12-week follow-up; no conflicts declared.)
  7. Jia K, et al. Comparative efficacy and safety of 1064-nm picosecond laser and 1927-nm fractional thulium laser for atrophic acne scars in Asian patients: a prospective, randomized, split-face study. Lasers Surg Med. 2026;58(6):447-454. https://doi.org/10.1002/lsm.70134 (Randomized split-face study, n=35, 80% skin type IV; compared with a picosecond laser, not CO2; 3 sessions; 12-week follow-up; publicly funded, no conflicts declared.)
  8. Li B, et al. Efficacy and adverse reactions of fractional CO2 laser for atrophic acne scars and related clinical factors: a retrospective study on 121 patients. J Cosmet Dermatol. 2022;21(5):1989-1997. https://doi.org/10.1111/jocd.14868 (Retrospective study, n=121; the scar-type difference had a wide confidence interval.)
  9. Polder KD, Bruce S. Treatment of melasma using a novel 1,927-nm fractional thulium fiber laser: a pilot study. Dermatol Surg. 2012;38(2):199-206. https://doi.org/10.1111/j.1524-4725.2011.02178.x (Small uncontrolled pilot; 3–4 sessions; improvement no longer statistically significant at 3 and 6 months.)
  10. Niwa Massaki AB, Eimpunth S, Fabi SG, et al. Treatment of melasma with the 1,927-nm fractional thulium fiber laser: a retrospective analysis of 20 cases with long-term follow-up. Lasers Surg Med. 2013;45(2):95-101. https://doi.org/10.1002/lsm.22100 (Retrospective case series; 1 session; recurrence in 7 of 15 at a mean of about 10 months.)
  11. Eisen DB, Asgari MM, Bennett DD, et al. Guidelines of care for the management of actinic keratosis. J Am Acad Dermatol. 2021;85(4):e209-e233. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jaad.2021.02.082 (Clinical practice guideline; makes no recommendation on 1927 nm lasers.)
  12. Levy T, Lerman I, Waibel J, et al. Expert consensus on clinical recommendations for fractional ablative CO2 laser, in facial skin rejuvenation treatment. Lasers Surg Med. 2025;57(1):15-26. https://doi.org/10.1002/lsm.23850 (Expert consensus panel; opinion, not trial data; ties to a CO2 laser maker.)
  13. Oliveira Modena DA, Melo Yamamoto AP, Ferreira da Silva TB, Oliveira Guirro EC. Thulium laser (1927 nm) for dermatological conditions: a systematic review. Lasers Med Sci. 2025;40(1):518. https://doi.org/10.1007/s10103-025-04781-5 (Systematic review; studies averaged 3 sessions at monthly intervals.)
  14. Chan NP, Ho SG, Yeung CK, Shek SY, Chan HH. Fractional ablative carbon dioxide laser resurfacing for skin rejuvenation and acne scars in Asians. Lasers Surg Med. 2010;42(9):615-623. https://doi.org/10.1002/lsm.20974 (Small study, n=9, skin types III–IV; single session.)
  15. Friedman PM, Dover JS, Chapas A, et al. 1,550 nm erbium-doped and 1,927 nm thulium nonablative fractional laser system: best practices and treatment setting recommendations. Dermatol Surg. 2022;48(2):195-200. https://doi.org/10.1097/DSS.0000000000003321 (Expert recommendations; opinion, not trial data; supported by a laser maker.)
  16. Bae YC, et al. Treatment of post-inflammatory hyperpigmentation in patients with darker skin types using a low energy 1,927 nm non-ablative fractional laser: a retrospective photographic review analysis. Lasers Surg Med. 2020;52(1):7-12. https://doi.org/10.1002/lsm.23173 (Retrospective photographic review, n=61, skin types IV–VI; low-energy settings.)
  17. Shamsaldeen O, Peterson JD, Goldman MP. The adverse events of deep fractional CO2: a retrospective study of 490 treatments in 374 patients. Lasers Surg Med. 2011;43(6):453-456. https://doi.org/10.1002/lsm.21079 (Retrospective review, skin types I–IV; a different CO2 device.)

Next
Next

What a Plasma Treatment Is Actually Like: A First-Timer’s Walkthrough, Rental Shoes Not Included